AdrienCordonnier

Differences between revisions 2 and 3
Revision 2 as of 2005-09-13 14:09:58
Size: 894
Editor: aaninen-20
Comment:
Revision 3 as of 2005-09-16 19:07:54
Size: 3507
Editor: st12-24
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 14: Line 14:
= Kubuntu Breezy Review =

I shifted from Mandriva to Kubuntu in June 2005. Mid September I tested Breezy. What I first enjoyed in Hoary was that it is nicely designed: cool default style and only great and usefull programs. The bad point was configuration, completely broken for network settings and not properly working for a lot of other things.

In Breezy, the configuration tools are quite good. It's clear that the development team has worked hard to fix this problem but on the other hand, the graphical interface seems to have been less polished and a lot of small displaying bugs have appeared.

Here is the list of small issues I noticed:
 * if updated from Hoary, the list of software become huge - doesn't keep the simplicity of Ubuntu;
 * on my 1280x800 screen, the KSplash image is not well rendered as the (same) Kdm background is;
 * when opening several session, the sound driver can't be shared (I think this bug was not in Hoary);
 * no icon for KThésaurus;
 * Krita is in Office submenu instead of Graphics one;
 * amaroK has become AmaroK in French, I don't think names should be changed in translation (already in Hoary);
 * amaroK version is quite "old", there has been already three stable release since;
 * Kuser does not crash anymore but creating a new ''useable'' user account is still not possible (already in Hoary);
 * the calculator is a lot better, congratulation! but I'd like to have one able to compute equations such as the TI92;
 * some System Settings modules are not yet translated;
 * some System Settings modules have not icon;
 * the System Settings window is badly resized each time you change module;
 * there are still some tiles as wallpapers, do some people really use such wallpapers? (not for disk space but for clarity in the list)
 * a lot of Konqueror protocols haven't any explication;
 * there is still a warning window when enabling some ACPI option in the last tab of <nowiki>KLaptopDaemon</nowiki> because of /usr/bin/klaptop_acpi_helper having a bad cheksum (already in Hoary);
 * the new document wizard in Krita has no option to set a customized size and resolution, the default resolution is 100px/inch whereas my screen resolution is 75px/inch;
 * most of the default fonts are quite ugly and they don't have any accent so it looks awful as soon as KSplash starts when the French localisation is set (the accentuated letters are replaced by a star);
 * by default, mp3 files can't be played! (even if I have 80% of my music in Ogg, it's very annoying);
 * by default, divx, xvid, mpeg files can't be seen! actually



Adresse électronique : MailTo(adrien_cordonnier AT PASDEPOURRIELS yahoo DOT fr)

About me

  • I am a 24 years French engineering student currently living in Finland;
  • I completely erased Windows from my hard in April 2001 to shift to GNU/Linux I had never used before. It has since been my only operating system.
  • I spent some time to help the French "Détaxe" workgroup - and eventually got a refund from Dell after refusing Windows EULA.

Links

The French "Détaxe" workgroup is somehow similar to any Windows Refund Action. The main difference is it tries to have consumption laws applied on computer market as several French laws forbid explicitely to link the sale of hardware and software (but strangely enough, the government does not act) : http://www2.aful.org/sections/wikis/detaxe/GdTDetaxeEnglish

Kubuntu Breezy Review

I shifted from Mandriva to Kubuntu in June 2005. Mid September I tested Breezy. What I first enjoyed in Hoary was that it is nicely designed: cool default style and only great and usefull programs. The bad point was configuration, completely broken for network settings and not properly working for a lot of other things.

In Breezy, the configuration tools are quite good. It's clear that the development team has worked hard to fix this problem but on the other hand, the graphical interface seems to have been less polished and a lot of small displaying bugs have appeared.

Here is the list of small issues I noticed:

  • if updated from Hoary, the list of software become huge - doesn't keep the simplicity of Ubuntu;
  • on my 1280x800 screen, the KSplash image is not well rendered as the (same) Kdm background is;
  • when opening several session, the sound driver can't be shared (I think this bug was not in Hoary);
  • no icon for KThésaurus;
  • Krita is in Office submenu instead of Graphics one;
  • amaroK has become AmaroK in French, I don't think names should be changed in translation (already in Hoary);
  • amaroK version is quite "old", there has been already three stable release since;
  • Kuser does not crash anymore but creating a new useable user account is still not possible (already in Hoary);

  • the calculator is a lot better, congratulation! but I'd like to have one able to compute equations such as the TI92;
  • some System Settings modules are not yet translated;
  • some System Settings modules have not icon;
  • the System Settings window is badly resized each time you change module;
  • there are still some tiles as wallpapers, do some people really use such wallpapers? (not for disk space but for clarity in the list)
  • a lot of Konqueror protocols haven't any explication;
  • there is still a warning window when enabling some ACPI option in the last tab of <nowiki>KLaptopDaemon</nowiki> because of /usr/bin/klaptop_acpi_helper having a bad cheksum (already in Hoary);

  • the new document wizard in Krita has no option to set a customized size and resolution, the default resolution is 100px/inch whereas my screen resolution is 75px/inch;
  • most of the default fonts are quite ugly and they don't have any accent so it looks awful as soon as KSplash starts when the French localisation is set (the accentuated letters are replaced by a star);
  • by default, mp3 files can't be played! (even if I have 80% of my music in Ogg, it's very annoying);
  • by default, divx, xvid, mpeg files can't be seen! actually


CategoryHomepage

AdrienCordonnier (last edited 2008-08-06 16:18:09 by localhost)