IceWeaselIcon

Differences between revisions 103 and 104
Revision 103 as of 2006-10-15 05:59:40
Size: 16243
Editor: c-71-226-119-122
Comment:
Revision 104 as of 2006-10-15 08:25:00
Size: 16668
Editor: adsl-68-95-130-76
Comment: Removed goatse "icon" again; please keep this junk out of the Ubuntu community
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 145: Line 145:
||DrX attachment:goatseweasel.png||I don't think it was a bad idea to remove this. If anyone disagrees, then they can fix it.|| ||(Icon in poor taste removed.)||I don't think it was a bad idea to remove this. If anyone disagrees, then they can fix it.||
Line 152: Line 152:
||||"Open process" my foot. This is nothing but a joke in very poor taste. It doesn't belong here, or anywhere really. I am removing it again, because I feel like I should add my support for standing up for good taste, and keeping things like this out of the Ubuntu community. But I will not remove it again, should someone else decide to put it back; I will leave that for someone else to show their support by acting.||

Put your IceWeasel icons here! There are also pages for the IceDoveIcon and the IceApeIcon.

See this forum thread: http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=273757

Use this template:

Nickname

Image

Comments

I'll start the icon list:

K.Mandla

attachment:IceWeasel-KMandla-Original.png

This is the original by K.Mandla -- I prefer IYY's version; I agree that it should be squarer, and I like the idea that the weasel should be bluer, which will make it look "icier." This one sticks to the Tango colors, but aside from that probably needs a little attention to get it within their guidelines. -- K.Mandla

-- The whole series of icons is gorgeous, but it would be pretty neat if the position of the Earth was changed so that Antarctica was in the center of view. Not only would it make the logos a bit "icier", it would make them more region neutral. -- TCH

I second that idea; using Antarctica is brilliant. :-)

K.Mandla

attachment:IceWeasel-KMandla-Revision.png

A revision -- This is closer to what I like. It's a bit of a cross between SlimDog360's #2 (with the blue-to-white gradients) and IYY's revision (with a squarer shape). I softened the tail a bit (I was looking at weasel tails and decided to make it less "fluffy") and removed the offside eye, which bothered me. This also uses the Gnome globe, which is GNU ... and GNUer is better! Har har. -- K.Mandla

-- This is a winner by my standards. Square, more blue and it uses a GNU image for the globe. Only problem i have is the current image shows up small on my panels compared to everything else, but im sure this will be fixed when its a .svg or whatever.. --Polygon

--I still prefer IIY's version. I don't like the gloss on the globe in this one, and you've lost the sparkle of the weasel's tail. Sorry, but I think this is a recession, rather than a revision...--T Smithe

-- I don't think that blue makes it icier... snow and ice are plain white not blue, it is also harder to see the weasel, since the earth is already blue. --Ferk

Looking at this on another monitor, it's almost too blue. The image of the weasel I traced it off was almost pure white, and I'm wondering if backing off the blue side and making it more white might also make it more distinguishable at smaller sizes. This might just turn into a blue blob at 48x48. -- K.Mandla

I really like the icon, but not the lighter spot on top of the globe. How about making a shadow moving over the globe, like day/night, for the page loading version? --HJH

GStubbs43 #2

attachment:GStubbs2-iceweasel-icon-mini.png

Comments:

GStubbs43 #3

attachment:GStubbs3-iceweasel-icon-mini-no-stars.png

Comments:

GStubbs43 #4

attachment:GStubbs4-iceweasel-icon-mini-no-star.png

Comments:

GStubbs43 #5

attachment:GStubbs5-iceweasel-icon-mini.png

Comments:

GStubbs43 #6

attachment:GStubbs6-iceweasel-icon-mini2.png

Comments:

GStubbs43 #7

attachment:GStubbs7-iceweasel.png

Comments:

GStubbs43 #8

attachment:GStubbs8-Applications-internet.png

Comments: Ha, I just realised this sort of looks like the .mac (netowrking) icon!

GStubbs43 #9

attachment:GStubbs9-Internet-web-browser.png

Comments: I think this would be the correct one... the icon was the reason of the problem... why to eliminate the icon?, else put firefox icon >,> --Biomega

GStubbs43 #10

attachment:GStubbs10-gino2_resized.png

Original icon is in attachments under GStubbs10-gino2.png (had to be resized)

Comments: -- I prefer this icon, as it uses the GNOME Globe and is released under a GNU Lisence, the others are Tango Globes, under a Creative Commons Lisence --GStubbs43

IIY

attachment:IIY1-iceweasel-icon-mini.png

Square weasel (head and body higher), no glowing nodes, tango colours.

Comments: EDIT: I like k.mandlas now, it has the suggestions i posted here.) I like this one the best, but i also like the blue weasel in SlimDog360's #2, maybe you could just make the weasel in this one blue like slimdogs. --Polygon

MarkRiedesel

attachment:iceweasel3sm.png

original icon can be found at [http://dugnet.com/klown/pics/iceweasel3.png dugnet.com]

Comments: Made from scratch in inkscape, I'm happy to assign whatever license is suitable.

This looks great ... can you put this under tri-license? and provide an svg? Can you make something similar for IceDoveIcon (Thunderbird) and IceApeIcon (SeaMonkey)? mail me at asac@debian.org as we need to push those IceLizards pretty soon.

I say it should be just like this one!!! it's so cute ., bsides it IS funny!! --hEvan

Umm -- this icon gives me a funny feeling on the inside. It gives a different feel than the Firefox one ... is that weasel humping the Earth? ~ ch4rm

You mean something like this? [http://mik.unpackable.org/humping_iceweasel.gif] Smile :) -- Faceless

I just love this icon. It's the one I'll use personally anyways. --Tribaal

By far the best Big Grin :) -- VincentZekred DateTime(2006-10-10T15:55:09Z)

Holy crap Faceless, that is freaking awesome Funny :)) *golf clap* - MarkRiedesel

It does looks great, although I would need to see a 32x32 versión. Scaling down this one doesnt get a result that great.--Ferk

I still prefer IIY and Kmandala's #2... this icon doesnt look all that great when its scaled down to a icon size and the weasel looks more like a white fox.--Polygon

Faceless' icon should be the throbber for Iceweasel, methinks Smile :-) MarkReidesel's original has the same look and feel as the other Mozilla product logos, which I like. - ChrisLees

Protip: Weasels do not have fox-like ears or fox-like muzzles. Riedesel's submission looks more like an Australian Brushtail Possum. - ChrisBaird

@ChrisBaird - Smaller/pointier chin and shorter/rounder ears? The upper-front part of the mouth is probably too wide as well, I'll tweak 'em after some sleep, thankw for the tips - MarkRiedesel

Warbo: I do like this one, but the face really needs tweaking to become more pointed, and it doesn't look "icy" enough for me. Also I feel sorry for whatever nation is under the crotch...

SlimDog360

attachment:slimdog360_1-iceweasel-icon2.png

Comments:

SlimDog360 #2

attachment:slimdog360_2-iceweasel-icon4.png

Comments:

SlimDog360 #3

attachment:slimdog360_3-transparentweasel.png

Comments:

TomElders

attachment:tomelders_iceweasel.png

It's late, I'm going home. Will do a bit more tomorrow.

gumara

http://static.flickr.com/109/266590076_0d5a5b0f9a_o.png

Comments: Sorry, I'm not big on this, it's just a different color of the Firefox icon, not sure Mozilla would like this anyway. ;)

hoibadraz

attachment:icemoose.png

Comments?

My favourite, looks weasely, looks icey, but I'd like more weasel and less globe (and darker too). - argie

I love this a lot, looks very bright, hopeful, whatever. iceweasel3sm.png is quite nice too but the weasel looks a bit sad.

Warbo: This looks great, but I wonder what would happen to the weasel when it gets scaled down? This is probably the only decent icon here which deviates from the "look 'n' feel" of the Firefox icon, instead of 'fox burning up on reentry' it is 'I am a friendly weasel who will help you browse the web'. (PS: If it doesn't get chosen, can I adopt the weasel? Pleeeeeease?)

LostInBrittany

attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_02_117x117.png attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_02_48x48.png attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_02_17x17.png

Here my take on the icons. As icons need to be good not only at full size but also at 48x48 et 17x17 (the size of the small icon in top of program window), I've made a PNG for each of the three sizes.

I think I like these best. I prefer the gray outline, especially for the ears. The blue continents emphasize the icyness, and I can't quite explain it, but this weasel's face is the...cutest. I think it will have wide appeal. The only suggestion I have is to add some color to the weasel itself, maybe a gradient or two; IMHO the solid color of the weasel clashes a bit with the globe.

LostInBrittany

attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_03_117x117.png attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_03_48x48.png attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_03_17x17.png

Here another version with darker contours for the weasel.

LostInBrittany

attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_04_117x117.png attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_04_48x48.png attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_04_17x17.png attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_05_17x17.png

A dark grey contour, looks better than black one IMHO. Edit: 17x17 shown twice, at left non retouched, at right passed by Gimp to get better definition.

I really like this; my favourite seems to change often... Then again, I don't know what new ones will be like! -- TSmithe

I really like this, and i like how you made it so that the small 17x17 icon stands out a lot more now. Good job, i think this is my favorite now (3rd time ive changed... haha) -- Polygon

LostInBrittany

attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_06_117x117.png attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_06_48x48.png attachment:iceweasel-icon_lostinbrittany_06_17x17.png

Testing left-headed weasel...

I prefer the other way round. I wonder (psychologically) why that is, and why most icons have so far been that way around. -- TSmithe

I think it has something to do with the direction we read and how that relates to viewing pictures in general, imagine if the Earth were a ball and sitting on a flat surface and started to roll, which way would it roll? I hypothesize that most of us native English readers (left to right) will assume that the ball will roll to the right, thus having the Weasel holding the ball on the right side keeps it in place and eliminates any potential movement in the icon and makes it aesthetically more appealing; I personally couldn't stand an icon that looks like it's about to move :> -- Cookiebearo

That is a very apt explanation, even on an arguable topic! -- T Smithe

I like this one the best, it seems like the weasel is supporting the globe, helping it stay steady instead of stopping it from moving. Some of that bias towards left-to-right movement I guess Smile :) -- jgoguen

gumara

http://static.flickr.com/80/267483545_c345320928_o.png

Comments?

Problem with this is that the icon is too rectangular, for a lot of stuff the icon has to be a square or else it will get squished and look really bad -- Polygon

Parkotron

http://static.flickr.com/97/267545331_110fa50c83_o.png

Obviuosly, it needs to be reworked by someone more skilled than myself, but I thought the icicle for the tail was an interesting addition. Also feel free to stick it on any globe you like. Source is available at http://ubuntuforums.org/showpost.php?p=1607619&postcount=73 --Parkotron

I think this suffers from the same unfortunate problem as MarkRiedesel's one above -- TSmithe

ursername180

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v355/ursername180/IceWeaselMine.png

Just some work I did. Not as good as many of the others here... Ohwell. Enjoy? --ursername180

Warbo: This looks good, but wouldn't really fit in with the default theme. I'm sure the Gartoon people would love it though.

ericesque

http://ekaschykresume.googlepages.com/iceweasel-icon-large.png

Obviously major credit goes to K.Mandla for the original concept, but I thought that the main color should be white and the blue accent 'hair' helped give the icon a bit more detail and firefoxyness --ericesque

Ahh, best one yet! Please, please post the SVG. I plan to use this regardless of what the official choice is. :-)

Wow, without a doubt my favourite so far! Not sure if that icon follows the Tango guidelines, but if not, it really should. Seems most GNOME apps are moving towards Tango icons, Iceweasel shold too :)

yeah, I'll get an SVG up later today. The icon does follow Tango guidelines fairly well. I still have some slight fine tuning ahead of me. I'll review the tango guidelines and make sure the icon is following them as closely as possible. Thanks for the positive feedback. Please remember this has been a collaborative effort of the community. I do not take credit for much of what you see. --ericesque

(Icon in poor taste removed.)

I don't think it was a bad idea to remove this. If anyone disagrees, then they can fix it.

Out from the darkness, The Ice Weasel springs forth triumphant!

is it wrong to delete stuff like this from the wiki?

Nope, so I just did. -- ["T Smithe"] DateTime(2006-10-14T09:03:03Z)

Undeleted -- an open process is essential. No one is forcing this to be the final icon.

If this gets chosen then I'm moving to BSD......

Mmm, gotta love the immaturity some people have. Do they honestly think that a icon based on goatse will be picked? yeah right. --Polygon

"Open process" my foot. This is nothing but a joke in very poor taste. It doesn't belong here, or anywhere really. I am removing it again, because I feel like I should add my support for standing up for good taste, and keeping things like this out of the Ubuntu community. But I will not remove it again, should someone else decide to put it back; I will leave that for someone else to show their support by acting.

esmucsi

http://img99.imageshack.us/img99/3438/porfinwq2.jpg http://img221.imageshack.us/img221/9651/porfin2jw5.jpg http://img237.imageshack.us/img237/6637/porfin3yh5.jpg

Comments:

Warbo: The one at the top left looks the best, although it does not seem to show a browser as clearly as the one underneath. Also, the Firefox-esque flaming tail effect doesn't really work here, it looks more like "Where the hell are my legs?"

Ruben85

http://www.qualias.net/rwbnshow/iceweasel/IceWeaselpub.png http://www.qualias.net/rwbnshow/iceweasel/IceWeasel256.png http://www.qualias.net/rwbnshow/iceweasel/IceWeasel64.png http://www.qualias.net/rwbnshow/iceweasel/IceWeasel32.png http://www.qualias.net/rwbnshow/iceweasel/IceWeasel16.png

Comments:

Based on a weasel on winter coat.

Beautiful work, but there are a couple of issues. Both the head and the tail are much too canine in appearance. For anyone who's interested, I found a great fullbody photo of a weasel here: ["http://www.mountainsofstone.com/images/Ermine%20on%20Porch.jpg"] -- Parkotron

Ruben85

http://www.qualias.net/rwbnshow/iceweasel/IceWeaselant1.png http://www.qualias.net/rwbnshow/iceweasel/IceWeaselant2.png

Comments:

Antarctica version of Weasel in winter coat. First as seen from space, second with Antarctica only.

Unfortunately, the nose reminds a rat or a panther rather than a weasel. Maybe you could only leave the tail? The logo should be simple IMHO.

GNU

http://www.gnu.org/software/gnuzilla/logo.png

Comments: I thought I'd put this on, it is the "official" GNUZilla logo, basically part GNU icon, part Mozilla icon.


CategoryArtwork

IceWeaselIcon (last edited 2011-03-09 13:10:35 by adsl-108-72-215-157)