InstallProgramsFromMigrationAssistant

Differences between revisions 1 and 2
Revision 1 as of 2009-06-18 21:23:26
Size: 2237
Editor: cpc5-hitc4-0-0-cust385
Comment: First draft (unfinished)
Revision 2 as of 2009-06-19 11:29:12
Size: 4451
Editor: cpc5-hitc4-0-0-cust385
Comment: Second draft (good enough for public view)
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 3: Line 3:
The [[https://launchpad.net/migration-assistant|Migration Assistant]] should offer to install (equivalents of) known programs during the installation process. The program should recognise three levels of equivalence: "port" (same codebase), "clone" (different codebase, but one is specifically modeled on the other), and "similar" (unrelated program that does the same job). The assistant should recognise at least the following packages: The [[https://launchpad.net/migration-assistant|Migration Assistant]] should offer to install (equivalents of) known programs during the installation process. The program should recognise three levels of equivalence: ''identical'' (same codebase), ''equivalent'' (different codebase, but one is specifically modeled on the other), and ''similar'' (unrelated program that does the same job). The assistant should recognise at least the following packages:
Line 7: Line 7:
 * GMail Notifier → GMail Notifier (clone)
 * mIRC → X-Chat (similar)
 * Pidgin → Pidgin (port)
 * Skype → Skype (port)
 * thunderbird → thunderbird (port)
 * xmms → Audacious (clone)
 * Audacity → audacity ''(identical)''
 * GMail Notifier → gmail-notify ''(equivalent)''
 * mIRC → xchat ''(similar)''
 * Pidgin → pidgin ''(identical)''
 * Thunderbird → thunderbird ''(identical)''
 * VLC -> vlc ''(identical)''
 * Winamp → audacious ''(equivalent)''
Line 14: Line 15:
Please add any applications that you would like to see included. Please add any applications that you would like to see included, then fill in [[#Implementation|below]] how they would be detected.
Line 22: Line 23:
Presenting this choice to the user also solves the perennial migrater's issue of "what's the Linux equivalent of ''program X''?". If the user is prompted to install a music program called Audacious, they're likely to figure out that this is the Linux equivalent of xmms. Presenting this choice to the user also helps with the perennial migrater's issue of "what's the Linux equivalent of ''program X''?". Migraters that are told "X-Chat is similar to mIRC" will know to look for X-Chat when they want mIRC.
Line 26: Line 27:
 * Over the past year, Willie has gradually switched from Outlook to Thunderbird, and from MSN Messenger to Pidgin. He wants to continue using these applications while he gets settled in to Linux  * Over the past year, Willie has gradually switched from his Windows-specific programs (e.g. MS Office, MS Outlook, MSN Messenger) to platform-neutral equivalents (e.g. !OpenOffice, Thunderbird, Pidgin). He wants to continue using these applications while he gets settled in to Linux
Line 31: Line 32:
An extra step will be inserted before "Migrate Documents and Settings" in the migration assistant. Existing Windows programs will be detected based on registry keys, and suggested to the user. Programs selected by the user will be installed along with the rest of the system, or scheduled for later installation if the computer doesn't have an Internet connection at install time. An extra step will be inserted before "Migrate Documents and Settings" in the migration assistant. Existing Windows programs will be detected based on registry keys, and suggested to the user. Programs selected by the user will be installed along with the rest of the system, or scheduled for later installation if the computer doesn't have an Internet connection at install-time.

= Implementation =

Wherever possible, the assistant should check in the registry for programs. This is more reliable than looking for telltale directories that could have been left after an uninstall, or installed in a non-default location.

Here are the registry keys that will be examined:

 Google Earth:: `HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\{1D14373E-7970-4F2F-A467-ACA4F0EA21E3}`
 Skype:: `HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\{24D753CA-6AE9-4E30-8F5F-EFC93E08BF3D}`
 GMail Notifier:: `HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\{0228e555-4f9c-4e35-a3ec-b109a192b4c2}`
 Pidgin:: `HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\Pidgin`
 VLC:: `HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\VLC media player`
 Audacity:: `HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\Audacity_is1`
 Thunderbird:: ''(still being checked)''
 WinAmp:: ''(still being checked)''

= Request for Comments =

Which (if any) of the following should be displayed, and should they be ticked by default?

 * Firefox → firefox ''(identical)''<<BR>>
 This would be installed anyway, but the user doesn't know that
 * MS Office → openoffice ''(similar)''<<BR>>
 This would be installed anyway, but the user doesn't know that
 * Acrobat reader → evince ''(similar)''<<BR>>
 This would be installed anyway, even though an identical application is available
 * Acrobat Reader → acroread ''(identical)'' <<BR>>
 This would not be installed because of evince.
 Most users consider PDF readers to be interchangeable commodoties, but some would like to know there's a choice
 * Skype → skype ''(identical)'' <<BR>>
 This is only available in the Medibuntu non-free repository
 * Google Earth → googleearth ''(identical)'' <<BR>>
 This is only available in the Medibuntu non-free repository

= Comments =

Summary

The Migration Assistant should offer to install (equivalents of) known programs during the installation process. The program should recognise three levels of equivalence: identical (same codebase), equivalent (different codebase, but one is specifically modeled on the other), and similar (unrelated program that does the same job). The assistant should recognise at least the following packages:

Mockup of the migration assistant installer

  • Audacity → audacity (identical)

  • GMail Notifier → gmail-notify (equivalent)

  • mIRC → xchat (similar)

  • Pidgin → pidgin (identical)

  • Thunderbird → thunderbird (identical)

  • VLC -> vlc (identical)

  • Winamp → audacious (equivalent)

Please add any applications that you would like to see included, then fill in below how they would be detected.

To the right is a rough mock-up of a possible interface.

Rationale

Users who migrate from another operating system always have a collection of programs that they use, and want to continue using. These can be far too esoteric to include in a default install, so the set of packages should be tailored to the specific user.

Presenting this choice to the user also helps with the perennial migrater's issue of "what's the Linux equivalent of program X?". Migraters that are told "X-Chat is similar to mIRC" will know to look for X-Chat when they want mIRC.

Use Cases

  • Over the past year, Willie has gradually switched from his Windows-specific programs (e.g. MS Office, MS Outlook, MSN Messenger) to platform-neutral equivalents (e.g. OpenOffice, Thunderbird, Pidgin). He wants to continue using these applications while he gets settled in to Linux

  • Humphrey is switching from Windows without any preparation. He has lots of Windows programs that he expects to somehow magically still be there when he installs Linux.

Design

An extra step will be inserted before "Migrate Documents and Settings" in the migration assistant. Existing Windows programs will be detected based on registry keys, and suggested to the user. Programs selected by the user will be installed along with the rest of the system, or scheduled for later installation if the computer doesn't have an Internet connection at install-time.

Implementation

Wherever possible, the assistant should check in the registry for programs. This is more reliable than looking for telltale directories that could have been left after an uninstall, or installed in a non-default location.

Here are the registry keys that will be examined:

Google Earth

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\{1D14373E-7970-4F2F-A467-ACA4F0EA21E3}

Skype

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\{24D753CA-6AE9-4E30-8F5F-EFC93E08BF3D}

GMail Notifier

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\{0228e555-4f9c-4e35-a3ec-b109a192b4c2}

Pidgin

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\Pidgin

VLC

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\VLC media player

Audacity

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\Audacity_is1

Thunderbird

(still being checked)

WinAmp

(still being checked)

Request for Comments

Which (if any) of the following should be displayed, and should they be ticked by default?

  • Firefox → firefox (identical)
    This would be installed anyway, but the user doesn't know that

  • MS Office → openoffice (similar)
    This would be installed anyway, but the user doesn't know that

  • Acrobat reader → evince (similar)
    This would be installed anyway, even though an identical application is available

  • Acrobat Reader → acroread (identical)
    This would not be installed because of evince. Most users consider PDF readers to be interchangeable commodoties, but some would like to know there's a choice

  • Skype → skype (identical)
    This is only available in the Medibuntu non-free repository

  • Google Earth → googleearth (identical)
    This is only available in the Medibuntu non-free repository

Comments

InstallProgramsFromMigrationAssistant (last edited 2009-06-28 19:06:43 by cpc5-hitc4-0-0-cust385)