MIR_List

Differences between revisions 34 and 35
Revision 34 as of 2017-05-24 21:56:58
Size: 3808
Editor: jbicha
Comment: mark gnome-shell as approved, but still waiting on gdm3
Revision 35 as of 2017-06-01 15:36:35
Size: 3934
Editor: jbicha
Comment: mark group 1 as Done
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 5: Line 5:
||gjs || || Bug:1683989 || Y || ||
||- mozjs38 || || Bug:1683937 || Y || ||
||gnome-control-center || Y || Bug:1685415 || Y || ||
||- gnome-settings-daemon || Y || Bug:1685414 || Y || ||
||- colord-gtk || Bug:1282372 || Bug:1685411 || Y || ||
||gdm3|| Y || Bug:1686393 || - || Even if we use lightdm, gnome-shell has a gdm3 dependency. Maybe this could be distro-patched to make it optional? ||
||caribou|| || Bug:1685867 || Y || Same for the caribou onscreen keyboard ||
||mutter || Bug:591162 || Bug:1685408 || Y || ||
||gnome-shell || || Bug:1685870 || Y || ||
||gjs || || Bug:1683989 || Done || ||
||- mozjs38 || || Bug:1683937 || Done || ||
||gnome-control-center || Y || Bug:1685415 || Done || ||
||- gnome-settings-daemon || Y || Bug:1685414 || Done || ||
||- colord-gtk || Bug:1282372 || Bug:1685411 || Done || ||
||gdm3|| Y || Bug:1686393 || - || Postponed since gnome-shell has been patched to make this optional. Maybe we can just use lightdm (Bug:1694962)||
||caribou|| || Bug:1685867 || Done || gnome-shell currently hard-depends on the gir for the caribou onscreen keyboard (onboard also requires caribou for some parts of gnome-shell) ||
||mutter || Bug:591162 || Bug:1685408 || Done || ||
||gnome-shell || || Bug:1685870 || Done || ||
Line 19: Line 19:
|| gnome-getting-started-docs || || Bug:1686726 || N || || || gnome-getting-started-docs || || Bug:1686726 || Done || ||

Main Inclusion Request List for GNOME transition

Group 1 (Must Have)

Package

In main before?

MIR bug #

Approved?

Comments

gjs

1683989

Done

- mozjs38

1683937

Done

gnome-control-center

Y

1685415

Done

- gnome-settings-daemon

Y

1685414

Done

- colord-gtk

1282372

1685411

Done

gdm3

Y

1686393

-

Postponed since gnome-shell has been patched to make this optional. Maybe we can just use lightdm (1694962)

caribou

1685867

Done

gnome-shell currently hard-depends on the gir for the caribou onscreen keyboard (onboard also requires caribou for some parts of gnome-shell)

mutter

591162

1685408

Done

gnome-shell

1685870

Done


Package

In main before?

MIR bug #

Approved?

Comments

gnome-getting-started-docs

1686726

Done

gnome-user-docs

Y

1687474

Done

gnome-initial-setup

N

chrome-gnome-shell

N

gnome-shell-extensions

N

provides GNOME Classic and several popular extensions, nice to have 'supported' in main if not installed by default

switcheroo-control

1691585

N


Group 3 (Easy MIR apps?)

Package

In main before?

MIR bug #

Approved?

Comments

gnome-tweak-tool

N

gnome-weather

N


Group 4 (Other)

Package

In main before?

MIR bug #

Approved?

Comments

epiphany-browser

Y

1689317

-

runtime for webapps

dconf-editor

597562

-

was once part of d-conf

evolution

Y

-

even if not shipped by default, might not hurt to have it 'supported' in main, has a few universe deps not listed here, was in default install until 2011. (Laney: We intentionally demoted it out of supported when it had obsolete deps. I don't personally see why we would take on maintaining another application if we're not using it, especially one that hasn't been trivial in the past.)

gnome-characters

N

instead of gucharmap

gnome-contacts

1463657

-

depends on email decision? because it might duplicate the email client? also depends on libchamplain and folks

gnome-logs

1522078

-

instead of gnome-system-log

gnome-maps

N

- folks

614221

-

Was in main until unity8 was dropped to universe after zesty

- libchamplain

1463659

-

- gfbgraph

N

gnome-sushi

N

Press space bar in Nautilus to preview a file

- libmusicbrainz5

N

- libdiscid

N

gnome-documents

N

multiple universe deps

gnome-music

N

We're using Rhythmbox for now

gnome-photos

N

We're using Shotwell for now, multiple universe deps

spice-vdagent

1200296

N

Better integration when run inside the GNOME Boxes virtualization app

fonts-cantarell

1387599

1685417

-

used in Shell by default if present, but we're using Ubuntu font now instead


Notes

  • Done means that is in main and in the default install
  • 'In main before?' should link to the approved MIR unless it was in main before Ubuntu had MIRs. In that case, just use Y for that field.
  • The Approved field allows us to easily see which MIRs have already been approved.
  • The Other category is for stuff that's not a priority now or maybe doesn't need to be in the default install or main.
  • The - in the first row is a basic form of nesting.
  • See MainInclusionProcess for how to file MIR bugs.

DesktopTeam/GNOME/MIR_List (last edited 2017-07-31 20:39:35 by jbicha)