Feedback

Differences between revisions 76 and 77
Revision 76 as of 2009-03-27 12:45:58
Size: 13869
Editor: ppp59-167-36-253
Comment: Adding result for Samsung NC10 (UK)
Revision 77 as of 2009-03-27 12:52:20
Size: 14020
Editor: host78-32-147-149
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 83: Line 83:

---- /!\ '''Edit conflict - other version:''' ----
Line 84: Line 86:

---- /!\ '''Edit conflict - your version:''' ----

---- /!\ '''End of edit conflict''' ----

Script problems

[NicolòChieffo]: my laptop does not automatically resume after 20 seconds. Where can I report it?

  • AndyWhitcroft: does it resume if you request it do so by hand? If so then this is an acpi wakeup issue and you should report it in launchpad at www.launchpad.net. Report it against the Ubuntu project linux package.

Script results

Hardware info and test results for https://wiki.ubuntu.com/KernelTeam/SuspendResumeTesting

Model

Video

Wireless

Kernel Version

Manual PASS/FAIL

Script PASS/FAIL

Bug #

Remarks

Apple Macbook Pro5.1

GeForce 9400M

2.6.28-6

FAIL

Has firmware issue unable to boot USB drive

Acer Aspire 2920

Intel GM965/GL960

Intel 3945 ABG

2.6.28-7

PASS

PASS 1-5, FAIL 6

Timeouts for auto-resume do not work - have to manually press power button to resume properly

Acer Aspire 5652WLMI

Nvidia Geforce Go 7600

Intel 3945 ABG

2.6.27-11

PASS

PASS

Acer Aspire 5920g

xserver-xorg-video-nv: nvidia 8600m gt

Intel 4965

2.6.28-6

FAIL

FAIL

324895

X server fails to start/had to manually resume the system

Acer Aspire 5920g

nvidia-glx-180: nvidia 8600m gt

Intel 4965

2.6.28-6

PASS

PASS

had to manually resume the system

Acer 9303WSmI

Nvidia GeForece 7600

Atheros

2.6.28-6

FAIL

To be filed

Acer Aspire One

Intel 945GME

Atheros AR242x

2.6.28-11.36

PASS

PASS

Manual wakeup required, Power consumption 32mW

Acer TravelMate 6592

ATI Radeon Mobility HD2400XT

Intel 4965

2.6.27-11

FAIL

Doesn't wake up after suspend.

Acer TravelMate 8106wlmi

ATI Radeon Mobility X700

Intel 2915ABG

2.6.28-9

FAIL

FAIL

#345064

Asus EeePC

Intel Mobile 945GME

Atheros AR242x

2.6.28-6

PASS

Asus EeePC 701SD

Intel Mobile 915GM/GMS/910GML

RTL8187SE

2.6.28-9

PASS

PASS

Asus EeePC 900

Intel Mobile 915GM/GMS/910GML

Atheros AR242x 802.11abg

2.6.28-8

PASS

PASS

Asus EeePC 1000

Intel Mobile 945GME

RaLink RT2860

2.6.28-8-generic

PASS

PASS

Asus P1-AH2 Server

nVidia GeForce 6150

None

2.6.28-8-server

PASS

PASS

Tested running the Ubuntu Server

Dell Inspiron E1405

Intel GM945

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

Has synaptic mouse issue

Dell E1505

Nvidia Gforce GO 7300

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell Inspiron mini 9

Intel 945GME

Broadcom

2.6.28-6

FAIL

FAIL

Timeouts for auto-resume do not work - have to manually press power button to resume properly

Dell Inspiron 1420

Intel GM965/GL960

Intel 3945ABG

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell Inspiron 1420

Intel GM965/GL960

Intel 4965AGN

2.6.28-8-generic

PASS

PASS

Dell Inspiron 1420

Intel 965

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell Inspiron 1520

Nvidia 8600M GT

Intel 3945 ABG

2.6.27-11

PASS

FAIL

Dell Inspiron 1521

ATI Radeon X1270

Broadcom BCM4311

2.6.28-11-generic

PASS

No problems encountered.

Dell Inspiron 1525

Intel GM965/GL960

Intel 3945ABG

2.6.28-7

PASS

Dell Inspiron 6000

ATI Mobile Radeon X300

Intel 2200BG

2.6.28-11

PASS

PASS

Dell Inspiron 6400

Intel 945

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell Inspiron 6400

Intel 945

Intel 3945

2.6.28-9

PASS

PASS

Suspend Battery 32mW

Dell Inspiron 6400

ATI Radeon X1400

Intel 3945

2.6.28-11

PASS

PASS

Battery Consumption: 56 mW

Dell Inspiron 8600

ATI RV350 [Mobility Radeon 9600 M10]

Intel 2915ABG

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell Inspiron 8600

NVidia GeForce FX Go5200

Intel 2200BG

2.6.27-11

PASS

PASS

Dell Latitude C600

ATI Rage Mobility M3 AGP 2x

2.6.28-7

FAIL

FAIL

329104

Dell Latitude D430

Intel GMA945

Intel 3945

2.6.28-8

PASS

PASS

Dell Latitude D430

Intel 945

Broadcom 4328

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell Latitude D620

NV G72M

BCM4311

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell Latitude D630

Intel GM965

Intel 3945ABG

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell Latitude D830

Intel GM965/GL960

BCM4311

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell M1330

Intel GM965

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell Studio 1537

Intel GM45 Express

Intel 5300 AGN

2.6.28-6

PASS

Dell XPS1330

Intel GM965/GL960

Intel 4965 AG or AGN

2.6.28-6

PASS

PASS

Intrepid install/Jaunty kernel

Dell XPS1330

NV 8400GS

Intel 4965

2.6.28-6

FAIL

???

Video issue on resume

Dell XPS1530

NVidia GE 8400

Intel 4965 AG or AGN

2.6.28-6

FAIL

324895

wifi doesn't work at all on boot

EEPC Intel

??

Atheros 5k

2.6.28-6

PASS

Fujitsu PSeries Lifebook

Intel 855GE

Intel 2200

2.6.28-6

PASS

successful 10 suspend/resumes - no need to manually resume

HP DV6245

Intel 945GM/GMS

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

HP Mini 1000

Intel GM945

Broadcom BCM4312

2.6.28-7

PASS

HP Mini 2133

Via CN896

BCM 4312

2.6.28-6

PASS

HP Pavilion dv7-1113eo

ATI Mobility Radeon HD 3450

Atheros AR242x

2.6.28-7-generic

FAIL

Keybord, touchpad not working after first resume.

HP Pavilion dv7-1132d, TurionX2

ATI RS780M/RS780MN

Atheros AR928X pci-x

2.6.28-6

FAIL

???

HP nw8440

ATI Mobility X1600

Intel 3945ABG

2.6.28-8

PASS

PASS

#328522

fixed

INMOVE (Asustek barebone) S37S

nvidia-glx-180: nvidia 8400m G

Intel 4965

2.6.28-7

PASS

PASS

Lenovo 3000 N100

Nvidia GeForce Go 7300

Intel 3945

2.6.28-11

PASS

FAIL

SD/MMC cardreader not working after resume. No automatic resume. Touchpad stops responding after 2nd resume. Keyboard stops responding after 5th resume.

Lenovo 3000 N200

Intel GM950

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

Lenovo R61

Intel GM965

Intel 3945abg

2.6.28-6

PASS

Lenovo R61

Intel 965GM

Intel 3945

2.6.28-11

PASS

FAIL

Energy consumption: 1214mW. With just battery, fails to wake itself up (tries to do so, but goes to sleep again, have to press suspend key combo)

Lenovo T60

Intel 945GM

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

PASS

Lenovo T61

Intel 965GM

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

Lenovo T61

Intel 965GM

Intel 4965

2.6.28-6

PASS

Energy consumption: 1400mW, with battery, fails to fakeup itself (tries to do so, but goes sleeping again, have to press powerbutton

Lenovo X200

Intel Mobile Series 4

Intel 5300

2.6.28-6

PASS

Lenovo X200

Intel Mobile Series 4

Intel 5300

2.6.28-8

FAIL

335570

Lenovo x200s

Intel GMA 4500MHD

Intel 5300

2.6.28-8

PASS

PASS

Lenovo x301

Intel GMA 4500MHD

Intel 5300

2.6.28-6

PASS

Lenovo X60 tablet

Intel GM945

Intel 3945ABG

2.6.28-6

PASS

Lenovo X60s

Intel 945GM

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

Lenovo X61s

Intel GM965/GL960

Intel 4965 AG or AGN

2.6.28-6

PASS

Lenovo X61

Intel 965

Intel 4965

2.6.28-6

PASS

Will sometimes hang after multiple suspend/resums; also suffers from know issue of immediate suspend after resume if using hotkeys to issue suspend

Lenovo X61

Intel 965

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

also suffers from known issue of immediate suspend after resume if using hotkeys to issue suspend

Lenovo X61

Intel 965

Atheros AR5212

2.6.28-6

PASS

Lenovo ???

NVS140M

2.6.28-6

FAIL

324895

X server in flat spin LP324895

Lenovo Ideapad S10e

Intel 945GME

Broadcom BCM4312

2.6.28-11

PASS

PASS

Macbook

Intel 945GM

Atheros AR5008

2.6.28-6

PASS

MacBookPro4,1

GeForce 8600M GT

Broadcom BCM4328

2.6.28-6

FAIL

324895

Xserver in a spin LP324895

MSI Wind U100

Intel GM945

Realtek 8187SE

2.6.28-8

PASS

PASS

Timeouts for auto-resume do not work - have to manually press power button to resume properly

MSI s262

Intel GM945

Intel 3945ABG

2.6.28-11-generic

PASS

MIXED

The script is terminated on the test where I unplug AC while suspended. Only the first test requires password when waking up. I'm using Option "AccelMethod" "UXA", otherwise graphics are really slow. I will try once without UXA, and see how it goes. UPDATE: The script works when UXA is commented out. Also confirming that only test number one requires password on waking up.

Panasonic CFY7J

Intel GM965

Intel 4965

2.6.28-6

PASS


Warning /!\ Edit conflict - other version:


Samsung NC10 (UK)

Intel 945GME

Atheros AR242x

2.6.28-11

PASS

PASS

Worked perfectly


Warning /!\ Edit conflict - your version:



Warning /!\ End of edit conflict


Samsung Q1U

?

Atheros

2.6.28-6

PASS

Self-built desktop

ATI Radeon HD 2400 PRO

n/a

2.6.28-7

PASS

PASS

Did not unplug power cord: desktop has no battery

Self-built desktop

Geforce 7600GT

n/a

2.6.28-11

PASS

PASS

Did not unplug power cord: desktop has no battery

Sharp D4 Intel Poulsbo

2.6.28-6

FAIL

???

Sony Vaio PCG-R600HFP (PCG-R505GC)

Intel i830m

Atheros AR5413

2.6.28-8

PASS

PASS

Option "NoAccel" "true" in xorg.conf, because of nonworking EXA/UXA

Sony Vaio PCG-5B1L

Intel 855GM

Intel 2200BG

2.6.28-9

PASS

PASS

336521

No backlight on resume

Sony VAIO SZ450N

GeForce Go 7400 Uses NV driver,

2.6.28-6

FAIL

324895

tested to fail with and without AC power & Wireless.

Sony VAIO SZ650N

Intel GM965/GL960

Intel 4965

2.6.28-11

PASS

PASS


Warning /!\ Edit conflict - other version:


Sony VAIO SZ650N

Nvidia GeForce 8400M

Intel 4965

2.6.28-11

FAIL

FAIL

Fails to resume, no automatic bug report


Warning /!\ Edit conflict - your version:



Warning /!\ End of edit conflict


Sony SZ660N

Intel GM965/GL960

Intel 4965

2.6.28-6

PASS

Sony SZ660N

Nvidia GeForce 8400M

Intel 4965

2.6.28-6

FAIL

324895

framebuffer driver

Thinkpad T23

S3 Inc. SuperSavage IX/C SDR (rev 05)

RaLink RT2500

2.6.28-11-generic

PASS

PASS

Starting an OpenGL application after resuming causes the system to hang. Fixed by xserver-xorg-video-savage 1:2.2.1-4ubuntu1. Audio is silent after resuming. Muting and unmuting Master and PCM makes sound work again.

Thinkpad T30

ATI Radeon Mobility 7500

Intersil Prism 2.5 Wavelan

2.6.28-7.20

PASS

PASS

Thinkpad T41

ATI Radeon 500

???

2.6.28-6

FAIL

Aironet <- doesn't resume (does from hibernate)

Thinkpad T42

Radeon Mobility M7 LW (7500)

ipw2200BG ([Calexico2])

2.6.28-6

PASS

Thinkpad T42

Radeon Mobility M7 LW (7500)

ipw2200BG ([Calexico2])

2.6.28-8.28-generic

PASS

PASS (see comment)

Did not auto-resume from the script if unplugged (but manual worked)

Thinkpad T42

Radeon Mobility 9600 M10

Atheros AR5212 ath5k

2.6.28-11-generic

PASS

PASS (see comment)

Did not auto-resume from the script if unplugged (but manual worked)

Thinkpad T42p

A M10 NT FireGL

Intel 2200BG

2.6.28-6

PASS

Thinkpad T-60

Intel 945

Intel 3945AVG

2.6.28-6

PASS

Hangs once in a long while

Thinkpad T60

ATI Radeon Mobility X1400

Intel 3945ABG

2.6.28-6

PASS

Thinkpad T60p 2007-CTO

ATI Technologies Inc M56GL [Mobility FireGL V5200]

Intel Corporation PRO/Wireless 3945ABG [Golan] Network Connection (rev 02)

2.6.28-6

PASS

Thinkpad T61

Intel GM965

Intel 4965agn

2.6.28-6

PASS

Thinkpad T61

NV 104M

Intel 4965

2.6.28-6

FAIL

324895

Video Issue on Resume

Thinkpad X40

Intel 855GM

Intel 2200BG

2.6.28-6

PASS

Thinkpad X41

Intel 915GM/PM/GMS/910GML

PRO/Wireless 2915ABG [Calexico2]

2.6.28-6

FAIL

Fails to resume automatically when power is disconnected. Manual resume works. Wacom does not work after suspend/resume (mouse tracking is off by about 6 inches)

Thinkpad X60

Intel 945GM

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

Thinkpad X61 Tablet

Intel GM965/GL960

Intel 4965 AG or AGN

2.6.28-6

PASS

Toshiba Satellite PSA70C-RX100E

Radeon Mobility 9100IGP

Atheros

2.6.28-11

FAIL

Status light goes back into "active mode" (blue) but the display does not wake up; same behaviour when triggered by suspend action on logout button

Toshiba Satellite A205-4577

Intel GM945

Intel 3945

2.6.28-6

PASS

Toshiba Satellite L300-19J

Intel 4500MHD

Intel 5100

2.6.28-6

FAIL

#324808

When resume, the HDD led lights up for a second or two, and after nothing.

Toshiba Satellite Pro A100

ATI Mob. Radeon X1400

Intel 3945ABG

2.6.28-11-generic

FAIL

FAIL

#343318

Doesn't wake up after suspend. Neither with the script nor manually. I attached more info to the bugreport.

Toshiba Satellite U300

Intel Mobile GM965/GL960

Intel PRO/Wireless 4965

2.6.28-6

PASS

Yakumo Q7M Mobilium Duo YW

Intel Mobile 945GM/GMS

Intel PRO Wireless 3945ABG

2.6.28-11-generic

PASS

PASS

KernelTeam/SuspendResumeTesting/Feedback (last edited 2011-09-05 18:57:18 by brad-figg)