MaverickAlpha3TestReport

Maverick Alpha 3 Test Report - 6th August 2010

Summary

Test Coverage

Image Coverage: 100%
Mandatory Testcase Coverage: 166/185 = 89.73
Optional Testcase Coverage: 19/40 = 47.50

Test Failure Analysis

22 Test Failures
Failure Rate 22/185 = 11.89

Bugs summary

Summary of Unfixed Issues

49 bugs unfixed

High - 10
Medium - 8
Undecided - 31

See section titled "Details of Unfixed Issues" below.

Summary of Fixed Issues

1 bug fixed

Low - 1

Summary of test failures

Kubuntu Alternate amd64 - Install (auto-resize)

LP: 151515 - missing resize option - Invalid - Medium
LP: 613550 - Input for http proxy was not presented - New - Undecided

Tester's comment: Comments:

Action-7: Guided Re-Size was not presented an option for installation. Install defaulted to Whole Drive Install. Thus, Action-8, 9 & 10 were not displayed or acted upon. It appears that bug 151515 covers this problem.

Action-16: I was not presented with the option to add http proxy. New Bug Reported: 613550.

Action-18: Before this step I was asked to Install Grub, which is not indicated on the action list. In order to proceed, I had to accept installing Grub, which is reasonable.

General Comments: Action-17. I did not see the slow down at 6%. The install went very quickly throughout.

New: 613550: No http proxy option

Existing Bug: 151515 No Resize Option

Overall the install went smooth accept where noted.

Kubuntu Alternate amd64 - Install (entire disk)

LP: 613582 - Log-In After Install Fails Maverick KUB-ALT-AMD64 - New - Undecided
LP: 613550 - Input for http proxy was not presented - New - Undecided

Tester's comment: Action-16: "Input http proxy" Same Bug 615330

Action-17: "Install System" Configure grub-pc step missing form test document.

New Bug Submitted: 613582

Action-20: "Long-In after Install" Failed: New Bug: First Time I installed with this method, I was able to log in.

Kubuntu Desktop amd64 - Live Session

LP: 580918 - video error - Incomplete - Undecided

Tester's comment: Case ID: dls 001 is OK, but there is the problem described in bug.

Case ID: dls 002 is KO, don't shut down, there is the problem described in bug.

Case ID: dls 003 is KO, don't start a persistent session, there is the problem described in bug.

Kubuntu Desktop amd64 - Live Session

LP: 580918 - video error - Incomplete - Undecided
LP: 613453 - [ISO TESTING] Live session KDM bugs kubuntu Mavrick - New - Undecided

Tester's comment:

Kubuntu Desktop i386 - Wubi (Windows installer)

LP: 613288 - wubi installation failed - boot configuration store could not be opened - New - Undecided

Tester's comment: Installation failed with message "boot configuration data store could not be opened"

Kubuntu Desktop i386 - Wubi (Windows installer)

LP: 600578 - installer drops into grub shell after rebooting from windows. - Incomplete - Undecided

Tester's comment:

Kubuntu DVD amd64 - Install (debian-installer)

LP: 613697 - Maverick Kubuntu amd64 DVD d-i install can't find installable kernel - New - Undecided

Tester's comment: d-i did not find any kernels. installation could not proceed.

Kubuntu DVD amd64 - Live Session

LP: 613453 - [ISO TESTING] Live session KDM bugs kubuntu Mavrick - New - Undecided

Tester's comment: tested on virtualbox OSE 3.2 Swiss/French, no installer on desktop and hang on at shutdown on 'casper is resyncing..'

Ubuntu ARM Preinstalled omap3 - Beagleboard ARM Image Testing

LP: 591941 - SDHC card not recognized - In Progress - High
LP: 613855 - omap3 beagle XM MMC card always comes up readonly - New - Undecided

Tester's comment: I tested on a beagle XM and a beagle C4 board, on the XM bug 613855 blocks installation, on the C4 it is 591941

Ubuntu Desktop amd64 - Install (auto-resize)

LP: 613071 - maverick ubiquity crashed when attempting a side-by-side install - Invalid - Undecided

Tester's comment:

Ubuntu Desktop amd64 - Install (manual partitioning)

LP: 613680 - When hitting continue testing option the Live Session logs out - Incomplete - Undecided
LP: 613685 - When selecting to not install bootloader on MBR I end up with no boot loader - Incomplete - Undecided

Tester's comment: I marked neither of these bugs serious because anyone using these options probably can deal with them.

The first ISO did not have these problems though and they are not something that the user should have to deal with.

Users with little experience would be screwed with the second one.

Selected to not install grub on sda and ended up with no grub on MBR.

Ubuntu Desktop i386 - Install (OEM setup)

LP: 613008 - failed to install oem-config from CD - Confirmed - High

Tester's comment:

Ubuntu Desktop i386 - Live Session

LP: 608382 - Maverick images build on lucid fail to boot - different syslinux version - Triaged - High

Tester's comment: syslinux wrong config

workaround with typing help on console.

other Tests passed.

Ubuntu Desktop i386 - Live Session

LP: 608382 - Maverick images build on lucid fail to boot - different syslinux version - Triaged - High
LP: 613276 - usb-creator doesn't copy files to usb drive unless it's opened with root privileges - Incomplete - Undecided

Tester's comment: Couple bugs in usb-creator.

Ubuntu Desktop i386 - Migration Assistant

LP: 613629 - Migration Assistant doesn't migrate anything on Maverick pre-A3 - New - Undecided

Tester's comment:

Ubuntu Desktop i386 - Wubi (Windows installer)

LP: 600578 - installer drops into grub shell after rebooting from windows. - Incomplete - Undecided

Tester's comment: Fails to get to the ubiquity install part.

Ubuntu Netbook Edition - Install (OEM setup)

LP: 613135 - Can't install fglrx on UNE 10.10 Alpha3 RC ISO - Invalid - Undecided
LP: 613694 - OSS driver does not work on UNE Live CD with my ATI card at all - Confirmed - Undecided

Tester's comment: Can't, even with xorg.edgers ppa drivers, get anything but a white screen.

Ubuntu Netbook Edition - Install (OEM setup)

LP: 613008 - failed to install oem-config from CD - Confirmed - High

Tester's comment:

Ubuntu Netbook Edition - Live Session

LP: 613135 - Can't install fglrx on UNE 10.10 Alpha3 RC ISO - Invalid - Undecided
LP: 613694 - OSS driver does not work on UNE Live CD with my ATI card at all - Confirmed - Undecided

Tester's comment: Desktop unusable with out something other than the default driver.

Fglrx uninstallable.

Ubuntu Server amd64 - UEC install (minimal topology)

LP: 609112 - [maverick] Registration unreliable - Confirmed - High
LP: 613463 - [10.10 - Alpha 3 (candidate)] Prompts misleading grub dialogs during UEC Node installation. - Confirmed - High

Tester's comment:

Ubuntu Server i386 - UEC install (minimal topology)

LP: 613514 - maverick i386 UEC: Instance does not start - New - Medium
LP: 613463 - [10.10 - Alpha 3 (candidate)] Prompts misleading grub dialogs during UEC Node installation. - Confirmed - High

Tester's comment: Lucky with registration the first time. Not so lucky with instance run.

Xubuntu Desktop i386 - Live Session

LP: 539878 - nouveau out of sync LVDS (basically card not supported) - Confirmed - High

Tester's comment: Hardware test; 2.2 GHz C2D; 2GB RAM; NVidia 8400M GS

* Nouveau renders screen unusable. User needs to manually add nouveau.blacklist=true to boot-options to get basic working desktop.

Xubuntu Desktop i386 - Wubi (Windows installer)

LP: 600578 - installer drops into grub shell after rebooting from windows. - Incomplete - Undecided

Tester's comment:

Details of Unfixed Issues

High

LP: 613008 - failed to install oem-config from CD - Confirmed - High
LP: 589204 - Evolution Setup Assistant dialog too large for netbook screens - Confirmed - High
LP: 609112 - [maverick] Registration unreliable - Confirmed - High
LP: 613463 - [10.10 - Alpha 3 (candidate)] Prompts misleading grub dialogs during UEC Node installation. - Confirmed - High
LP: 606373 - cloud-init output does not get to console when booted with pv-grub and ramdisk - Confirmed - High
LP: 539878 - nouveau out of sync LVDS (basically card not supported) - Confirmed - High
LP: 608382 - Maverick images build on lucid fail to boot - different syslinux version - Triaged - High
LP: 591941 - SDHC card not recognized - In Progress - High
LP: 605739 - BUG: Bad page state in process swapper pfn:94d23 - In Progress - High

Medium

LP: 608047 - ica crashed on login with SIGSEGV in gtk_container_add() - happens every login - New - Medium
LP: 613022 - ssh daemon hangs after publickey packet sent - New - Medium
LP: 613514 - maverick i386 UEC: Instance does not start - New - Medium
LP: 566818 - [Lucid] cryptsetup passphrase prompt during boot: every character typed repeats the prompt - Confirmed - Medium
LP: 613625 - ubiquity crashed with AttributeError in on_extra_combo_changed() - Confirmed - Medium
LP: 605831 - Resolution should be taken from /proc/cmdline if provided - Triaged - Medium
LP: 600359 - ureadahead generating oom messages during boot. - In Progress - Medium

Undecided

LP: 613582 - Log-In After Install Fails Maverick KUB-ALT-AMD64 - New - Undecided
LP: 613453 - [ISO TESTING] Live session KDM bugs kubuntu Mavrick - New - Undecided
LP: 613636 - Kubuntu Maveric ISOs show purple "Ubuntu 10.10" boot splash instead of the blue Kubuntu one. - New - Undecided
LP: 613288 - wubi installation failed - boot configuration store could not be opened - New - Undecided
LP: 613697 - Maverick Kubuntu amd64 DVD d-i install can't find installable kernel - New - Undecided
LP: 613834 - DIfficult to find "Prepare for Shipping" applet in OEM install on Kubuntu Maverick - New - Undecided
LP: 613836 - After first reboot of Maverick, user is presented with a page telling user he/she must have an opendesktop.org account - New - Undecided
LP: 613839 - Maverick A3 Kubuntu 64bit OEM install is installing netbook instead of desktop - New - Undecided
LP: 613879 - Maverick A3 Kubuntu 64bit OEM install is installing netbook instead of desktop - New - Undecided
LP: 613606 - netbook-launcher-efl running as an app in gnome desktop, not as standalone desktop. - New - Undecided
LP: 613612 - Favorites missing from netbook-launcher-efl - New - Undecided
LP: 613866 - u-boot loaded from SD should look to SD for boot.scr instead of using nand settings. - New - Undecided
LP: 613855 - omap3 beagle XM MMC card always comes up readonly - New - Undecided
LP: 613591 - Jasper sometimes fails to resize root partition on omap4 - New - Undecided
LP: 604501 - A second Maverick installation, in top of Windows/Maverick won't add a grub entry for self - New - Undecided
LP: 614167 - After installing, Maverick doesn't prompt to remove the LiveUSB before rebooting. - New - Undecided
LP: 613629 - Migration Assistant doesn't migrate anything on Maverick pre-A3 - New - Undecided
LP: 613083 - user-data is corrupted inside metadata service - New - Undecided
LP: 613273 - kernel panic on ec2 in system_call_fastpath - New - Undecided
LP: 590998 - update-apt-xapian-index crashed with DatabaseLockError in init() - New - Undecided
LP: 613034 - Xubuntu splash screen is showing Ubuntu 10.10 - New - Undecided
LP: 613041 - Xubuntu documentation needs to be updated from 9.10 to 10.10 - New - Undecided
LP: 613054 - xfce4-mixer muted on login - New - Undecided
LP: 568643 - Missing jockey notification icon in xfce-panel in Xubuntu - New - Undecided
LP: 613694 - OSS driver does not work on UNE Live CD with my ATI card at all - Confirmed - Undecided
LP: 580918 - video error - Incomplete - Undecided
LP: 600578 - installer drops into grub shell after rebooting from windows. - Incomplete - Undecided
LP: 613680 - When hitting continue testing option the Live Session logs out - Incomplete - Undecided
LP: 613685 - When selecting to not install bootloader on MBR I end up with no boot loader - Incomplete - Undecided
LP: 613276 - usb-creator doesn't copy files to usb drive unless it's opened with root privileges - Incomplete - Undecided
LP: 613550 - Input for http proxy was not presented - New - Undecided

QATeam/ReleaseReports/MaverickAlpha3TestReport (last edited 2010-08-06 07:24:32 by p54BE1460)

Ubuntu Wiki